Five individuals had been arrested as of Tuesday.
According to Tisch, three people who had previously been connected to robbery trends throughout the city were taken into custody the day following the assault.
The fifth suspect, a 16-year-old serial offender, was taken into custody Tuesday morning after a fourth suspect turned himself in on Sunday.
The suspects are charged with reckless endangerment, instigating a riot, and attempted criminal assault.
Yeferxon Jose Mijares Hernandez, a 19-year-old adult, was taken into custody on Sunday and is charged with multiple offenses, including attempted assault and second-degree riot.
The attack happened shortly before 7:30 p.m., minutes before a big boxing event between Ryan Garcia and Rolando Romero at a nearby location, according to NYPD.